When we talk about fountain pens, especially in the realm of high-quality writing instruments, three names almost always rise to the top: Montblanc, Pelikan, and Lamy. These three German brands have carved their own space in the market, each with its own unique identity, design philosophy, and target audience. In particular, the Montblanc 149, Pelikan M800, and Lamy 2000 stand as hallmarks of their respective lineups. But how do they compare to one another? Which one is the best fit for you, depending on your writing habits and personal preferences?

Let’s dive into a detailed exploration of these iconic pens, analyzing their design, nib quality, performance, and overall feel to help you understand which might be the best for your needs.

Previously I have already reviewed the 149 and you can also check out the written review and more photos at awritingguy.com - speaking of the website, if you haven’t noticed already, the shop is up and running so I’m putting out a promo code to give back to you guys for all your support! Products are being added gradually and each and every single one of your orders also support the growth of this channel and thank you for helping me do this fulltime!

Use the code PLAIN at check out for 10% off orders with the “plain notebook”.

Montblanc 149: Tradition and Luxury in Your Hand

Design and Build Quality

If there is one pen that has become a cultural icon beyond the realm of fountain pen aficionados, it’s the Montblanc Meisterstück 149. Often referred to as the “Diplomat” pen, the 149 embodies old-world European luxury with modern engineering finesse. Montblanc pens are often associated with prestige, and the 149 sits proudly at the top of their collection, rivaled only by limited editions and bespoke models.

From the moment you hold the Montblanc 149, there’s an undeniable heft and presence to it. The sleek, black precious resin body combined with the signature white snowcap logo at the top of the cap gives the pen an unmistakable appearance. Its size is something to note—it’s a large pen, meant to make a statement. This is not the kind of pen that hides quietly in your pocket. The gold or platinum accents on the trim, depending on your preference, add a touch of grandeur, completing a design that is steeped in tradition yet retains a timeless appeal.

As someone who has held and used multiple high-end pens, I find the Montblanc 149’s design to exude a sense of importance. The cap threads on with a satisfying smoothness, and uncapping it feels like a ritual every time. However, the 149 can be too much for those with smaller hands or those who prefer a less conspicuous writing tool. Its size and weight are designed to impress, but they can feel unwieldy during long writing sessions if you’re not used to it.

Nib and Writing Experience

The Montblanc 149’s nib is arguably its defining feature. Crafted from 18k gold, the nib is both visually stunning and highly functional. The 149 comes in a variety of nib sizes, from extra-fine to broad, and even specialty nibs or bespoke nibs such as oblique or double broad. The flexibility of these nibs, though not as pronounced as vintage gold nibs, offers a smooth, consistent writing experience. The nib glides effortlessly over paper, and while there’s a hint of feedback, it’s never scratchy. It feels controlled yet free—like a well-tuned sports car on a smooth road.

The ink flow is generous, which means the Montblanc 149 isn’t the best choice for cheap or thin paper. I found it works best with higher-quality paper, where the ink can settle in without feathering or bleeding. This isn’t a pen for hurried note-taking; it’s for savoring every stroke.

Personal Opinion on the Montblanc 149

There’s no denying that the Montblanc 149 is a luxury item. I see it as the kind of pen that’s meant to be displayed on a desk, uncapped for signatures or special moments, rather than being used for everyday journaling or scribbling. If you’re someone who appreciates tradition, legacy, and the allure of a well-known brand, the 149 will speak to you. However, I wouldn’t consider it the most practical pen for regular, extended writing sessions. It’s too heavy and large for that, in my opinion, and its size demands a specific kind of setting—one that mirrors the gravitas of the pen itself.

Pelikan M800: Precision and Reliability in Every Stroke

Design and Build Quality

The Pelikan M800 may not have the same luxury image as the Montblanc 149, but in the world of serious fountain pen users, it is every bit its equal. Pelikan is known for its engineering prowess, and the M800 is a testament to German precision. The pen’s design is classic without being ostentatious. Its striped barrel, often available in green or blue, evokes a sense of understated elegance. It’s a pen that says “serious writer,” without needing the added flair of Montblanc’s gold and platinum accents.

One of the standout features of the Pelikan M800 is its piston-filling mechanism. Unlike the cartridge-converter systems found in many other pens, the M800’s piston system is smooth and highly efficient. The ink capacity is generous, and refilling is a breeze. The M800 feels solid in the hand, but not overly heavy. Its balance is perfect for long writing sessions, and the size, while substantial, isn’t as overpowering as the Montblanc 149.

In my personal opinion, the Pelikan M800 strikes a perfect balance between form and function. It’s a pen that you can comfortably use all day without feeling fatigued. The design is beautiful, but in a more reserved way compared to the Montblanc 149.

Nib and Writing Experience

The M800’s nib is where this pen truly shines. Pelikan’s nibs are known for their smoothness and reliability, and the 18k gold nib on the M800 is no exception. The writing experience is buttery smooth, with just the right amount of ink flow. There’s a certain “softness” to the way the nib interacts with the paper—an almost cushiony feel that makes long writing sessions a pleasure. Pelikan is one of those odd ball brands that every individual nib feels different on the page - no 2 M nibs write the same, and I mean it in a good way. They do not possess the machine-like consistency of Montblanc, but all their nibs have their own characters and will provide you with awesome writing experience nonetheless.

Pelikan nibs are also somewhat customizable. The nibs on the M800 are interchangeable, meaning you can swap out nib sizes without having to buy an entirely new pen.

From my experience, the M800 offers a slightly less “wet” writing experience than the Montblanc 149, making it more versatile on a variety of paper types. I’ve used it on everything from regular notebook paper to high-end cotton paper, and it performs consistently well.

Personal Opinion on the Pelikan M800

The Pelikan M800 is my go-to recommendation for anyone who wants a fountain pen that can do it all. It’s a workhorse, but one with the finesse and grace of a much more expensive pen. I find the M800 to be perfect for everyday use, whether it’s for quick notes, journaling, or writing long letters. It’s not as flashy as the Montblanc, but it’s just as dependable—if not more so. It’s the kind of pen that quietly gets the job done, every single time.

Lamy 2000: Modern Minimalism Perfected

Design and Build Quality

The Lamy 2000 is a different beast entirely. Where the Montblanc 149 and Pelikan M800 are steeped in tradition and classic design, the Lamy 2000 is a product of modernist minimalism. Designed in 1966 by Gerd A. Müller, the Lamy 2000 is a testament to the Bauhaus philosophy of form following function. Its design is sleek, almost industrial, with a body made of Makrolon (a polycarbonate material) and brushed stainless steel. There are no gaudy trims or embellishments—just clean lines and a subtle matte finish.

Holding the Lamy 2000 feels different from most fountain pens. It’s lightweight, but not flimsy. The clip, while simple, is functional and adds to the overall minimalistic look. The piston-filling mechanism is almost invisible, blending seamlessly with the pen’s body. The Lamy 2000’s design is one that I’ve grown to appreciate more over time. It’s not the kind of pen that immediately wows you with its looks, but rather one that earns your admiration through its simplicity and practicality.

Nib and Writing Experience

The nib on the Lamy 2000 is unlike the nibs on the Montblanc 149 or Pelikan M800. It’s a hooded nib, which means only the tip is exposed, giving the pen a unique look and feel. The nib is 14k gold, but it’s coated in platinum, giving it a more understated appearance. Writing with the Lamy 2000 is an incredibly smooth experience. The nib glides effortlessly across the page, and the ink flow is perfectly balanced—not too wet, not too dry.

One thing I love about the Lamy 2000 is how well it performs on all types of paper. I’ve used it on everything from cheap office paper to high-quality Rhodia pads, and it handles each with aplomb. There’s very little nib feedback, which can be a downside if you prefer more “tooth” to your writing experience, but for those who enjoy a smooth, frictionless feel, the Lamy 2000 is a dream.

Personal Opinion on the Lamy 2000

For me, the Lamy 2000 is the ultimate “everyday” pen. It’s not about making a statement, and it doesn’t carry the same weight of prestige as a Montblanc 149 or Pelikan M800, but that’s what makes it so refreshing. The design is so utilitarian that it becomes invisible in the best possible way—this is a pen you use, not a pen you show off. It’s practical, comfortable, and designed to meet the demands of the modern writer.

What I particularly appreciate is how easy it is to carry around. Unlike the Montblanc 149, which feels like it needs its own padded box for protection, the Lamy 2000 can be thrown into a bag or pocket without much worry. It’s sturdy, reliable, and surprisingly affordable compared to its luxury counterparts. If you’re someone who appreciates minimalist design or simply needs a tool that works flawlessly, day in and day out, this pen is likely to find a special place in your life.

Comparing the Montblanc 149, Pelikan M800, and Lamy 2000

Having explored each pen individually, let’s now compare the Montblanc 149, Pelikan M800, and Lamy 2000 across several key dimensions: design, nib quality, writing performance, and value for money. These factors should give you a clearer picture of how they stack up against one another.

Design and Aesthetics

• Montblanc 149: The Montblanc 149 is a statement piece. Its large size, glossy black resin, and gold or platinum trim are undeniably luxurious. The Montblanc logo on the cap instantly elevates the pen to a status symbol, signaling wealth, success, and refined taste.

• Pelikan M800: In contrast, the Pelikan M800 is elegant without being flashy. The striped barrel and conservative design make it a pen for those who appreciate subtlety and craftsmanship. It’s refined but not attention-seeking, blending form and function beautifully.

• Lamy 2000: The Lamy 2000 is the opposite of both. It’s the epitome of modern minimalism. No glossy finishes, no precious metal trims—just a sleek, utilitarian design rooted in Bauhaus principles. Its Makrolon body is tough but unassuming, making it perfect for those who prioritize functionality and understated aesthetics.

Nib Quality and Writing Performance

• Montblanc 149: The 18k gold nib of the Montblanc 149 is legendary for its smoothness. It lays down a generous amount of ink, perfect for those who prefer a wet, expressive writing style. The nib offers some feedback, but it’s controlled and responsive, making it ideal for elegant signature writing and special correspondence.

• Pelikan M800: The Pelikan M800’s nib is also 18k gold and offers a slightly firmer writing experience compared to the Montblanc. It’s well-balanced in terms of ink flow, making it ideal for both everyday writing and more formal occasions. The M800’s nib tends to have less flex than the Montblanc, making it slightly better suited for those who need precision and reliability.

• Lamy 2000: The Lamy 2000’s hooded 14k gold nib is a revelation in smoothness. It writes effortlessly, with almost no feedback, making it perfect for long writing sessions. The nib isn’t as wet as the Montblanc’s, nor as firm as the Pelikan’s—it sits somewhere in the middle, making it an ideal everyday writer. It’s less flashy, but just as competent.

Comfort and Usability

• Montblanc 149: The Montblanc 149 is a large, weighty pen. While its heft makes it feel substantial and luxurious, it can become tiring during extended writing sessions. It’s better suited for short bursts of writing, such as signing documents or jotting down notes.

• Pelikan M800: The Pelikan M800 strikes the best balance between size and comfort. It’s substantial enough to feel premium but not so heavy that it causes hand fatigue. The weight distribution is near-perfect, making it a joy to use for extended periods.

• Lamy 2000: The Lamy 2000 is lightweight and comfortable, designed for long writing sessions. Its minimalist design allows it to disappear in your hand, providing a smooth, distraction-free experience. If you’re writing for hours on end, the Lamy 2000 is the most comfortable of the three.

Value for Money

• Montblanc 149: The Montblanc 149 is undeniably expensive. You’re paying for the brand name, the craftsmanship, and the status that comes with owning a Montblanc. While the writing experience is superb, the high price tag means that much of what you’re paying for is the luxury factor rather than pure functionality.

• Pelikan M800: The Pelikan M800 offers excellent value for money. It’s still a premium pen, but you’re paying for quality engineering and a stellar writing experience, rather than the brand alone. The M800 is for people who appreciate substance over style, and it’s worth every penny for those who write frequently.

• Lamy 2000: In terms of pure functionality, the Lamy 2000 is a steal. It offers a writing experience on par with far more expensive pens but at a fraction of the price. The Lamy 2000 is the best value for money of the three, especially for those who prioritize minimalism and performance over luxury.

Which Pen Is Right for You?

At the end of the day, choosing between the Montblanc 149, Pelikan M800, and Lamy 2000 depends on your personal needs, preferences, and the kind of statement you want your pen to make. Here’s a summary of who might benefit most from each pen:

• Montblanc 149: If you’re someone who values tradition, prestige, and luxury, the Montblanc 149 is your pen. It’s perfect for executives, business leaders, or anyone in a high-profile profession where making a statement matters. The 149 is a status symbol, a pen that’s as much about being seen as it is about writing.

• Pelikan M800: The Pelikan M800 is ideal for serious writers, academics, or professionals who need a reliable, high-performing pen for daily use. It’s not as flashy as the Montblanc, but it offers a better balance of comfort, functionality, and elegance. If you’re someone who appreciates fine craftsmanship and values performance over prestige, the M800 will suit you perfectly.

• Lamy 2000: The Lamy 2000 is the pen for creatives, designers, and minimalists. Its Bauhaus-inspired design is perfect for those who value simplicity and efficiency. The Lamy 2000 is a tool for getting things done, without the distraction of luxury embellishments. It’s the best choice for those who need a dependable everyday pen that won’t break the bank.

The Final Verdict

Each of these pens brings something unique to the table. The Montblanc 149 is a bold statement of luxury and tradition, the Pelikan M800 is a workhorse of precision and elegance, and the Lamy 2000 is a minimalist masterpiece of modern design. Ultimately, the best pen for you depends on how you plan to use it and what you value most in a writing instrument.

For those who want to make a statement and enjoy the finer things in life, the Montblanc 149 is an iconic choice. If you’re looking for a reliable, high-performing pen that balances elegance and practicality, the Pelikan M800 is hard to beat. And if you appreciate modern design, value, and functionality, the Lamy 2000 offers an unparalleled writing experience at an unbeatable price.

No matter which pen you choose, you’re investing in a tool that will elevate your writing experience for years to come. Choose wisely, and enjoy the journey.

Once again, for more written reviews, articles and more please check out awritingguy.com and if you would like to support me by buying something from the shop, use the code PLAIN at check out for 10% off your order with the plain looking notebook! Thank you and I’ll see you in the next one!